Rekey or Replace Your Locks? What Tampa Homeowners Need to Know
You just moved into a new home.
Or maybe your tenant just left.
Or you lost your keys… and now you're wondering:
“Should I rekey my locks — or replace them completely?”
This guide will help you make the right decision for your Tampa home. We’ll break it down step by step — no fluff, just what you need to know.
Table of Contents
1. What Does "Rekeying" Actually Mean?
Rekeying is when we change the internal pins of your current lock to work with a new key, without replacing the entire lock hardware.
You keep the same lock on the door.
But the old keys will no longer work.
It’s fast, affordable, and secure — especially if your locks are still in good shape.
Learn more about rekeying here »
2. What Is Lock Replacement?
Replacing a lock means removing your existing hardware and installing a new deadbolt, knob, or smart lock system.
This is ideal if:
Your current locks are old or worn
You want to upgrade to smart locks
You want stronger security (high-security bump-proof, pick-proof)
We carry a wide range of new locks from brands like Schlage, Kwikset, Yale, and Level Lock.
3. Rekey vs Replace: Which One Is Cheaper?
Here’s the truth:
Option Avg. Cost Per Lock Key Benefits
Rekey $25–$45 Fast, low-cost, secure
Replace $75–$250+ New hardware, upgrade opportunities
Rekeying is typically 3–5x cheaper than replacement.
4. When You Should Rekey
Rekeying is usually the better option when:
You just moved into a new home
A roommate, guest, or ex had a copy of your key
You lost your key, but the lock is still strong
You want to match multiple locks to one key
You want a quick, same-day security update
Schedule a rekeying in Tampa now »
5. When You Should Replace
You should replace your locks if:
Your current locks are rusted, loose, or jam frequently
You're upgrading to smart locks or keypad systems
You want bump-proof, pick-resistant locks
You want better curb appeal (new handleset or color)
Lock replacement is more of a long-term investment in hardware quality + visual design.
6. What Most Tampa Homeowners Choose
Based on hundreds of jobs across the Tampa area, here's what we’ve seen:
Scenario Most Popular Option
Just bought a new home Rekey (85%)
Tenant just moved out Rekey
Break-in attempt Replace
Locks over 10 years old Replace
Want one key for whole house Rekey
Switching to keyless entry Replace
House was recently remodeled Replace for style
Just lost a single key Rekey
Still not sure? We can inspect your locks and give you our recommendation — no pressure.
7. Cost Comparison Table
Item Rekey Replace
Average Price (per lock) $25–$45 $75–$250+
New Keys Included ✅ Yes ✅ Yes
Change who can access ✅ Yes ✅ Yes
Works with Smart Locks ❌ No ✅ Yes
Improve visual appearance ❌ No ✅ Yes
Time Required 10–15 mins/lock 20–30 mins/lock
Security Upgrade Potential Moderate High
8. Smart Locks: Where Do They Fit In?
Smart locks are considered lock replacements — but they’re more than just new hardware.
They give you:
Keyless entry
Mobile app access
Code tracking and logs
Auto-lock timers
Integration with Alexa, Google, Apple
We install the most trusted brands in Tampa:
Schlage Encode, Yale Assure, Level Lock, Nest x Yale, Ultraloq
Explore our Smart Lock options »
9. FAQs
Q: Can I rekey the locks myself?
Only if you have the exact pin kit, plug follower, and key blank — and know what you're doing. Otherwise, it’s easy to damage the lock.
Q: How long does rekeying take?
10–15 minutes per lock. A full 3-bedroom home usually takes about 45–60 minutes.
Q: Will rekeying affect my door or lock appearance?
Not at all. Everything is internal — your lock will look the same.
Q: Can I rekey multiple locks to use the same key?
Yes — as long as the locks are the same brand or compatible cylinder type.
Q: What’s the most secure lock to install?
We recommend ANSI Grade 1 deadbolts and bump-resistant smart locks for homes.
10. Get Help Rekeying or Replacing in Tampa
Still not sure whether to rekey or replace?
We’ll inspect your locks, give our honest advice, and help you secure your home fast — often same-day.
📞 Call Now: (813) 534-2911
📲 Or Text Us
📅 Book Online in 30 Seconds
Serving: Westchase, Carrollwood, Riverview, Seminole Heights, Brandon, South Tampa, and all surrounding areas.
