Rekey vs Replace Locks in Tampa: Which One Do You Really Need?
Just Moved In? Someone Might Still Have a Key…
Whether you're a new homeowner, a recent renter, or recovering from a break-in, one question comes up fast:
Should I rekey the locks — or replace them completely?
This guide gives you a clear, expert breakdown so you can:
Save money while staying 100% secure
Know exactly what to ask your locksmith
Avoid unnecessary hardware costs
Feel confident in your choice — today
Table of Contents
What Is Rekeying a Lock?
When Should You Rekey?
When You Must Replace Your Locks
Pros & Cons of Each Option
Real Prices in Tampa (2025)
FAQ: Rekey vs Replace
Final Security Tip from Our Experts
1. What Is Rekeying a Lock?
Rekeying means changing the internal pins inside your existing lock so old keys no longer work — and only your new key does.
It’s fast, affordable, and perfect if the hardware is still in good shape.
2. When Should You Rekey?
Rekeying is ideal when:
You just moved into a new home or apartment
A roommate or ex-partner moved out
You lost a copy of your key
A contractor or cleaner had temporary access
You want all doors to work with one key
Cost in Tampa: $25–$45 per lock (plus service call)
3. When You Should Replace the Locks
Full replacement is necessary when:
The lock is damaged, rusted, or loose
You want to upgrade to smart locks
You’ve had multiple break-ins
You want to change the style or color
The lock is outdated or doesn’t meet insurance specs
Cost in Tampa: $90–$300 per lock depending on type
4. Pros & Cons
Option Pros Cons
Rekey ✅ Fast, cheap, secure ❌ Can’t upgrade appearance
Replace ✅ Total upgrade, new hardware ❌ More expensive, takes longer
Still unsure? Text us a photo of your lock — we’ll tell you in 30 seconds.
Text “LOCK” to (813) 534-2911
5. Real Prices in Tampa (2025)
Rekey 1 Lock: $25–$45
Rekey 3–5 Locks (Bundle): $90–$150
Replace Basic Lock: $90–$120
Upgrade to Smart Lock: $180–$350
Service Call (Tampa Metro): $29–$59
Discounts available when bundled with move-in packages or multi-door jobs.
6. Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is rekeying secure enough for a new home?
Yes. If the locks are in good condition, rekeying provides full security by disabling all old keys.
Q: Can you rekey a smart lock?
Some, yes — especially models with keyholes. Others may need full reprogramming or replacement.
Q: How fast can you rekey my house?
Same-day service available. Most jobs take 30–60 minutes total.
7. Pro On The Go Tip: When In Doubt, Start with Rekeying
If you’re unsure what to do, we recommend rekeying first. It’s fast, secure, and saves you money. You can always upgrade hardware later if needed.
Just moved in? Ask about our New Home Security Package.
Ready to Rekey or Replace Your Locks?
Call 813-534-2911 for immediate assistance.
BOOK ONLINE — 30 SEC FORM
TEXT “REKEY” to (813) 534-2911
We serve all of Tampa — including Ybor City, Carrollwood, Brandon, South Tampa, and more.
Real Review from a Tampa Homeowner:
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“I had no idea rekeying was even an option. Jerry saved me over $300 by rekeying my locks instead of replacing them. Fast, friendly, and super professional.” — Eli R., Tampa, FL
About Pro On The Go Locksmith™
We’re Tampa’s most trusted mobile locksmith — helping residents rekey, upgrade, and secure their homes every day. No games. Just fast, honest service.
